I don’t know how, but I’d never heard of this trilogy until the movie The Golden Compass came out, and even then I didn’t pay much attention. It wasn’t until I was creating my fill in the gaps list (and someone at work recommended them to me) that I really looked into them. Set in parallel universes, it’s the coming of age story of Lyra Belacqua (I’m so infatuated with her name!) and Will Parry. It’s also a critique of organised religion, and (thanks Google!) an inversion of the epic poem Paradise Lost by John Milton.
While there were some bits I didn’t like, on the whole I really enjoyed reading these books. The doomed lovers bit at the end just annoyed me, but I find all doomed lovers annoying. (This is probably more a reflection on me than the books.) Occasionally I found Pullman’s style a little grating and overly wordy, but to be fair, the scene where Lyra says goodbye to Pan when she sets off for the land of the dead made me bawl my eyes out so it did its job. (I was on the train coming home from work at the time. Embarassed much?)
After I’d finished reading the books I clicked around on some reviews on the interwebs, and found a lot of reviews blasting the books as Anti-Christian. I don’t think that’s true at all, I think the books are against organised religion, or at least the negative aspects of it, but I don’t think there’s any point in there where Pullman is trying to turn us all into atheists.
This morning I started reading Neverwhere by Neil Gaiman. By the time I got to Flinders Street I thought I was on the London underground. If it wasn’t for the fact that I need to at least look like I’m doing work, I’d be reading it right now. Instead, I am eating speckles that I just bought at Haighs, and feeling so sad for this kid.
God bless you, Briony, for using WordPress, which I can use to leave comments without encountering the FireWall of Doom. This is not the case with Blogger.
For myself, I bawled at several points. Since HDM was my undergraduate thesis, I’m ABSOLUTELY HORRIFIED to see that you were not completely and utterly enamored of it. But I’ll do my best to put that aside in order to wholeheartedly agree with you; while Pullman himself is pretty much a die-hard atheist, I don’t think HDM is an atheistic piece of work. Too much is made of the whole “killing god” thing. They weren’t killing god–they were setting him free!
That was one of my favourite parts of the whole trilogy – the image of releasing God.
If it helps, I am completely and utterly enamored with the name Lyra! And the mulefa – they were my favourite characters in the whole trilogy. I really enjoyed the books, but the wordiness just got exhausting after awhile =D